Table of contents

Big Agnes Captain Comfort Deluxe Camp Sleeping Pad Review

Tested by: Jory Brass

We independently test everything we recommend.
Buying through links on our site supports our work.

We are a reader-supported website and do not accept payment from manufacturers to promote their products. When you click on some of the links on our site and make a purchase, we earn a small commission at no cost to you. This keeps our website running and enables us to provide independent, high-quality outdoor resources free of charge.
The Captain Comfort propped up against a picnic table shows horizontal air cells that provide comfort and support
The horizontal air cells (faintly visible) make it easier to roll up and pack the Big Agnes Captain Comfort. – Photo Credit: Jory Brass (cleverhiker.com)

Bottom Line

The Big Agnes Captain Comfort Deluxe is one of the plushest self-inflating camping mattresses we have tested. Five inches of foam-and-air support helped our testers get a particularly good night of sleep near White Sands National Park, and the tall profile provides welcome forgiveness for varied sleeping positions. The same volume that makes it comfortable is what makes it difficult to compress when the trip ends. We especially recommend it to car campers who want a deep adjustable bed and do not mind rolling twice. For perspective on its competitors, see our best camping mattresses guide.

How We Tested

Gear Analyst Jory Brass evaluated the Captain Comfort Deluxe during spring camping near White Sands National Park, where it delivered one of his most restful nights in the test. He also participated in months of side-by-side comparisons against thick car-camping competitors, assessing support in several sleeping positions, insulation, inflation and deflation, accessory design, and packed bulk.

Quick Specs

big-agnes-captain-comfort-deluxe-camp-sleeping-pad

Big Agnes Captain Comfort Deluxe

Thickest Luxury Camping Mattress

CleverHiker Rating: 4.7/5.0

Price: $280

Dimensions (LxWxH): 78 x 30 x 5 in.

Weight: 6 lb. 6 oz.

Style: Self-inflating

R-Value: 8.3+

Pros

  • Five-inch sleep surface
  • Supportive & soft
  • Two inflation valves
  • Very high insulation rating

Cons

  • Hard to compress completely
  • Bulky & heavy
  • Pump sack can detach
Our testers rests on a blue Big Agnes camping mattress after it self-inflated
Our tester rests on the Big Agnes Captain Comfort – one of our favorite luxury sleeping pads. – Photo Credit: Jory Brass (cleverhiker.com)

Comfort

Five inches makes a big difference for the sleepers who press through thinner pads at the shoulders or hips. During Jory Brass’s car-camping tests near White Sands National Park, the Captain Comfort was among the models that delivered the best night’s sleep. Its extra loft remained a clear distinction in side-by-side tests at home rather than merely looking impressive on a specification sheet. The Captain Comfort Deluxe offers enough depth to make the ground feel distant, and we found its foam-and-air combination exceptionally comfortable in several positions. It is a distinctly different feel from a low, firm pad like the REI Campwell.

There is a real reason to consider the HEST Foamy instead: its all-foam construction avoids any air-bed sensation. Yet the Captain Comfort’s ability to tune inflation pressure makes it a strong choice for campers who want similar plushness with more adjustability.

Comfort Score: 4.8/5.0

A tape measure shows the Captain Comfort Deluxe Camp is legitimately 5 inches thick
The Captain Comfort Deluxe is the thickest mattress we tested at 5 inches. – Photo Credit: Jory Brass (cleverhiker.com)

Ease of Use

The twin valves move air into the mattress as its foam expands. Topping it off can take more work, and the included pump sack sometimes proved awkward to keep attached. None of these issues was enough to erase its comfort advantage after setup.

Deflation requires patience. The long horizontal air cells simplify rolling relative to some foam-heavy designs, but cannot change how much material needs compressing. We found that the two large valves let air out quickly at first; the last air trapped within the thick foam was the challenge. Our testers often rolled the large mattress once to drive out the initial air, then unrolled and repeated the process before it fit neatly. The side-loading storage sack is practical once the core is adequately compressed, but it cannot eliminate the effort.

Ease of Use Score: 4.5/5.0

A cell phone time runs next to a self-inflating camping mattress that's slowly taking in air.
We timed how long it took for the Captain Comfort to self-inflate to evaluate its ease of use. – Photo Credit: Jory Brass (cleverhiker.com)

Warmth

An R-value of at least 8.3 makes insulation one of this pad’s most compelling specifications; some sizes are rated as high as 9.9. The score measures resistance to heat escaping into the ground, not heat generated by the mattress itself. That distinction matters for choosing an appropriate winter sleeping system, rather than assuming the pad alone will keep you warm.

It is far better suited to chilly campground ground than thin warm-weather airbeds. Its foam also makes it a useful candidate when campers expect wide overnight temperature swings. No rating replaces the need for suitable sleeping bags and weather planning.

Warmth Score: 5.0/5.0

Our tester rolling up the mattress from bottom to top
Plan on rolling the Captain Comfort twice to expunge enough air for it to fit inside its stuff sack. – Photo Credit: Jory Brass (cleverhiker.com)

Packed Size

The 17-by-11-inch roll is relatively short but thick. It is about the size of a typical packed sleeping bag, and the side-loading duffel has a handle for carrying it between car and campsite. The design is easier to fill than a narrow top-entry sack once the pad has been fully compressed.

That shape may fit certain cargo compartments better than the long narrow rolls of other self-inflating pads. Weighing over six pounds, it is plainly a car-camping mattress. Do not confuse its shorter pack length with backpacking portability.

Packed Size Score: 4.0/5.0

The Captain Comfort packed up next to a picnic table in a New Mexico campground
The Captain Comfort takes up as much space as most sleeping bags. – Photo Credit: Jory Brass (cleverhiker.com)

Should You Buy the Big Agnes Captain Comfort Deluxe Camp sleeping pad?

Buy it when the priority is the thickest possible adjustable camping bed and you can allocate extra time to pack. Couples and side sleepers looking for cushion will appreciate what Big Agnes built. If easy deflation is more important than extra loft, a thinner mattress will be less frustrating.

The Captain Comfort in its duffle-style carrying case set on a boulder in the desert
The Captain Comfort’s packed size is similar to a sleeping bag’s. – Photo Credit: Jory Brass (cleverhiker.com)

What Other Camping Mattresses Should You Consider?

If the Captain Comfort isn’t in your wheelhouse, consider some alternatives from our camping mattresses guide: 

Therm-a-Rest MondoKing 3D Review: The MondoKing is longer at 80 inches and has a softer, quieter top material. It offers slightly less loft, making the decision a trade between length and maximum thickness.

HEST Foamy Review: The Foamy eliminates inflation entirely and offers exceptional winter warmth, but its enormous fixed-volume roll is harder to accommodate in a small vehicle.

NEMO Roamer Double Review: Are you looking for copious comfort for two? The Roamer Double is extra-thick, super-soft, and sized up for two people or a camper and a pet.

A male tester stares at striated red rock while laying on his side on the Big Agnes Captain Comfort
The Captain Comfort shrugged off dust, rocks, burrs, and cactus spines when testing in a red rock canyon. – Photo Credit: Jory Brass (cleverhiker.com)