Table of contents

REI Trailmade 25 Review

Tested by: Marion Tucker

We independently test everything we recommend.
Buying through links on our site supports our work.

We are a reader-supported website and do not accept payment from manufacturers to promote their products. When you click on some of the links on our site and make a purchase, we earn a small commission at no cost to you. This keeps our website running and enables us to provide independent, high-quality outdoor resources free of charge.
A person sits inside a sleeping bag on top of a bear canister. They sit in front of a tent with mountains in the background.

Bottom Line

The REI Trailmade 25 is a versatile entry point for campers who want one affordable sleeping bag for car camping and short backpacking trips. Nine length-and-width combinations help more body types find a proper fit, while Marion Tucker’s field testing confirmed that its stated 31°F comfort rating matches the low-30s conditions where the bag felt best. The soft liner and uncomplicated hood and collar round out a practical sleep setup.

This is still a tapered synthetic mummy, not a plush campground rectangle or an ultralight down bag. Active stomach sleepers may dislike the restricted lower fit, and a mesh storage sack is not included. Choose the REI Siesta for stretch-out car-camping comfort or the Kelty Cosmic Down for more efficient packing. See our best camping sleeping bags guide for more.

How We Tested

We evaluated the Trailmade 25 in both tent and van camping, checking its warmth against the listed comfort rating and assessing the hood, collar, zipper, fabric, and packed volume. The published test also discusses the nine length-and-width configurations and changes from the preceding Trailmade 20. Those firsthand observations support the recommendations below.

Quick Specs

rei-co-op-trailmade-25-sleeping-bag

REI Trailmade 25

Most Inclusive Camping Sleeping Bag for All Shapes & Sizes

CleverHiker Rating: 4.6/5.0

Price: $129

Temperature Rating: 25°F

Weight: 2 lb. 15.1 oz.(Medium)

Fill Type: Synthetic

Pros

  • Nine length and width options
  • Affordable for an entry-level crossover bag
  • Soft, quiet lining
  • Practical hood and draft collar
  • Warm in low-30s field use
  • Small enough for short backpacking trips

Cons

  • Tapered mummy cut is restrictive for some
  • No mesh storage sack
  • Not as packable as premium down
The CleverHiker Budget Buy Badge Logo with a sleeping bag picture in the middle
A close up of the top half of a sleeping bag.
The REI Trailmade 25 uses a cushy synthetic fill that’s warm in cooler temps. – Photo Credit: Marion Tucker (CleverHiker.com)

Comfort

The Trailmade 25 is unusually accessible because REI offers nine length-and-width combinations. That makes it easier to find a mummy bag that matches your frame without excess dead air space or an unnecessarily tight upper body. The soft, quiet liner and shaped footbox also help it feel approachable to campers moving beyond basic rectangular bags.

Even with that extensive sizing, the tapered mummy cut won’t satisfy everyone. Side sleepers who curl sharply or stomach sleepers who like to spread out may prefer the Siesta’s broad rectangle. A larger Trailmade size may improve movement, but it also means extra space for your body to heat.

Comfort Score: 4.7 / 5.0

A close up of a plastic toggle and cord of a sleeping bag hood.
The Trailmade 25’s hood cinches for a snugger fit thanks to a cord and toggle system. – Photo Credit: Marion Tucker (CleverHiker.com)

Warmth

REI lists the Trailmade 25 at 25°F and assigns a 31°F comfort rating. Our tent and van testing found the bag most comfortable in the low 30s and warmer, so the published comfort rating is unusually realistic for this category. The recycled synthetic insulation is spread through horizontal baffles that reduce gaps in coverage.

Its cinchable hood, shoulder collar, and zipper draft tube contribute to that field performance. The DWR-treated shell helps when condensation is present, although users still need a suitably insulated pad and dry sleep setup. Trips substantially colder than the low 30s call for a warmer bag.

Warmth Score: 4.5 / 5.0

A close up of a sleeping person's face amidst a sleeping bag.
The hood on the Trailmade 25 keeps your head well insulated. – Photo Credit: Marion Tucker (CleverHiker.com)

Packed Size

At 2 lb. 15.1 oz. in the published medium size, the Trailmade 25 is plausible for short backpacking trips as well as the car campground. It is lighter than the earlier Trailmade 20, and the mummy profile yields a smaller bundle than wide rectangular synthetic bags. That portability broadens its usefulness for new backpackers.

Synthetic insulation won’t compact as tightly as down, so this is still not a specialist ultralight bag. REI does not include a mesh storage sack, and a breathable container is preferable for keeping the fill lofted between trips.

Packed Size Score: 4.7 / 5.0

A close up of a sleeping bag enclosed in a stuff sack. A person holds the bag.
The REI Trailmade 25 packs into a stuff sack that’s a convenient compact shape. – Photo Credit: Marion Tucker (CleverHiker.com)

Features

REI focuses on practical details: a hood with an elastic cinch, an insulated shoulder collar, a full-length two-way zipper, and a stash pocket inside the bag. Moving the pocket inside from the preceding Trailmade means a headlamp or phone is within reach without releasing warmth through the main zipper.

The zipper slides smoothly in most of our testing, though the bottom slider can be finicky. The published review also notes that the zipper lacks a double-sided slider, so adjustments from inside are less effortless than on some competitors. Recycled shell and fill materials are worthwhile without making the bag harder to use.

Features Score: 4.4 / 5.0

A close up of a smartphone sticking out of a sleeping bag stash pocket.
An internal stash pocket makes it easy to keep your phone nearby. – Photo Credit: Marion Tucker (CleverHiker.com)

Should You Buy the REI Trailmade 25?

Choose the Trailmade 25 if you want an affordable first camping bag that can also manage short backpacking outings. Its nine size combinations broaden the audience, and field testing supports its low-30s comfort rather than relying on the colder nominal 25°F rating. Straightforward draft protection, a quiet liner, and reasonable packed weight add to the appeal.

Pass if your priority is a big rectangular sleeping space or if you need down-level compression for frequent backpacking. The REI Siesta offers much more lounging room for car camping, while the Cosmic Down 20 offers a smaller down bundle for trips with a longer carry.

A person crouches on the ground and shoves a sleeping bag into a stuff sack. They kneel beside a tent with mountains in the background.
It’s not difficult to pack the REI Trailmade 25 into a stuff sack. – Photo Credit: Marion Tucker (CleverHiker.com)

What Other Camping Sleeping Bags Should You Consider?

Kelty Cosmic Down 20 Review: The Cosmic is a step toward a more packable down backpacking bag while keeping a relatively approachable price. It was comfortable around 30°F in the Colorado field test and stuffs smaller than the synthetic Trailmade, but its narrow mummy cut offers less sizing flexibility and costs more.

REI Siesta Hooded 20 Review: If you don’t plan to backpack, the Siesta offers a wide rectangular interior, pillow-compatible hood, and softer weighted-blanket feel. Its bulk and weight are far less convenient to carry, so stick with the Trailmade when crossover use is central.

An empty sleeping bag lays on the ground outside a tent. There are mountains in the background.
The REI Trailmade 25 is a mummy bag available in nine unique sizes. – Photo Credit: Marion Tucker (CleverHiker.com)